Tag Archives: RIAA

Content producers want to give government the ability to censor the Internet #SOPA

PROTECT IP Act Breaks The Internet from Fight for the Future on Vimeo.

The Internet is one of the greatest advancements in human history. It’s not hyperbole to suggest that the Stop Online Piracy Act could diminish not only the Internet but modern civilization. I’ll be linking to different people’s opinions on the bill the rest of the day and this week.

Here are some key points:
  • Safe harbor, the provision that protects ISPs and websites such as YouTube from being liable for what users do on their networks and sites, would be eroded. You can post copyrighted material to YouTube, but it’s not the purpose of the site, and Google has tools built in to allow those infringing submissions to be taken down. Google is currently not legally liable that some users don’t follow copyright law. That could change under this new law.
  • Court orders from the Department of Justice could stop search engines from linking to supposed infringing sites.
  • Internet service providers could be asked to block their users from accessing black listed sites.
  • Any ISP, ad network, search engine, payment processor, domain registrar, etc that takes voluntary action against a supposed infringing site will be given legal immunity. This means there are no penalties for false positives. There is no incentive for being overzealous.
This is nothing like the Internet that we all know and love.
For more information, I strongly suggest checking out what the EFF has to say about SOPA. They have a lot of different posts about the act, so search around.

ISPs form new Copyright Alert System that will alert users of copyright infringement

This is a step in the right direction. Instead of just randomly suing people when a music label or movie studio suspects copyright infringement, ISPs will notify people that a copyright holder believes a copyright infringement has occurred:

The entity announced today that AT&T, Verizon, Comcast, Time Warner Cable and Cablevision have teamed up with the RIAA and MPAA in order to agree upon a six-stage notification system that’ll electronically alert internet users whenever their account is used for wrongful downloading.

Under no circumstances will this system result in your Internet being cut off. The UN considers Internet access a human right, and it shouldn’t be shutoff just because a company believes copyright infringement may have occurred. This new system is a lot more user friendly, and hopefully it will lead to less litigation and more education and awareness of what is and isn’t legal.